this love has got no ceiling
'When you consider McCandless from my perspective, you quickly see that what he did wasn't even particularly daring, just stupid, tragic and inconsiderate. First off, he spent very little time learning how to actually live in the wild. He arrived at the Stampede Trail without even a map of the area. If he had a good map he could have walked out of his predicament using one of several routes that could have been successful. Consider where he died. An abandoned bus. How did it get there? On a trail. If the bus could get into the place where it died, why couldn't McCandless get out of the place where he died?'
--Alaskan Park Ranger Peter Christian
"There are no blank spaces left on any map.If you want to really get out there, you have to leave the map behind."
--Jon Krakauer, paraphrased from the Sundance Channel series Iconoclasts
"Some people feel like they don't deserve love. They walk away quietly into empty spaces, trying to close the gaps of the past." --Christopher McCandless
First, I think Peter Christian is a wanker. Yeah, I know, attack the position and not the person, yadda yadda. Well, I think Peter Christian's musings on Christopher McCandless' choices are wanker worthy.
I've been blogging (in my head) about "Into the Wild" (the movie) for two solids weeks now. More than that, even. S. and I saw it the day after Thanksgiving at 11 a.m.--there was barely a soul in the theater. I was mesmerized. The cinematography was stunning--and I'm not just talking the Alaska footage. I loved the South Dakota shots, the color of the wheat, Emile Hirsch (who plays Christopher McCandless)learning to ride a tractor with Vince Vaughan by his side. And the music...can we say Eddie Vedder? Wrap this film up to go. I need to keep it in my pocket for the rest of my life.
Fuck all the bullshit I've read about how the movie is too long or it's one big Sean Penn-ism...I even read one reviewer who thought the movie needed "more F-16's." Niiiiice. Gotta have the violence because actually FEELING something REAL is too much. Sean Penn may be a lot of things, and he may have acted like a total horse's ass for years, but I'll give him this: he's not afraid of emotion. Hard emotion. He's not afraid to court danger, not afraid to be reduced to a sobbing mess by what amounts to a story of courage, strength, hubris and love. Remember people: It's all about love. "When you forgive, you love." (Ron Franz, from the movie)
Ah, but for some it's about stupidity. For some it's about the basic inability to understand why the fuck anyone in his right mind would burn all identification and money and set out alone, mapless, into the wilds of Alaska. I've read that the abusive McCandless family environment depicted in the film was more exaggerated than the real thing. We'll never really know. I think Penn chose to emphasize what Chris was running from so that the average person could hang their hat on a REASON why Chris disappeared. After all, no sane person would ever do what he did, right? He had to be a little touched, damaged goods, forced to reject the world because the world handed him an abusive, greed-and-status-driven family. We just can't wrap our heads around the fact that abandoning all convention was a CHOICE.
From the time the book, Into the Wild, hit bookstores to the time the film version was released, more than a decade had passed. Then one day Walt McCandless calls Jon Krakauer and says "Okay, we're ready to make the movie." Krakauer calls Penn, asks if he's still interested. Without hesitation (or, according to Krakauer, after a three second pregnant pause), Penn says Yes.
The film took two years to shoot. Penn was determined to remain true to the route McCandless took, which is probably one of the reasons for the film's length. I never thought there was too much detail, however...it seemed like we needed all the pieces Penn included in order to put the puzzle of McCandless' life together. The film is, after all, a character-driven drama, and the people Chris encounters along his journey shaped the person he was to become, almost as much as his family history shaped the person he was before setting out. Almost.
I'm not really here to dissect the details of the movie, however. What I want to put into words, if I can, is how much of an impact the movie had on me. I can say, honestly, that it changed my life a little. It made me want to be a better person. I feel more compelled to risk, to take chances, even if everything (or everyone) says No, don't do that. Setting off without a map was deliberate on the part of McCandless, and though many may think that this "stupid" move was what killed him--it very well might have been--I refuse to give in to the notion that he died in vain. Most likely he died in pain, but his death is one small chapter in a much larger story. Death is inevitable. Self-discovery isn't.
Rejection of capitalism, a hatred of convention--I think this was a part of Chris' thinking but I don't believe it was a motivating force. He seemed most interested in feeling as deeply as he could, challenging himself both physically and mentally and damn anything that got in his way. Like art, it's not about the end result, it's about the process. We all die. But will we die with the knowledge that we put our dreams within our sights and then went for it? Will we leave this life fearlessly, certain that we plunged the very depths of darkness and pain, will we find peace in the heart's truth that we experienced pure ecstasy and joy? So many scenes from the film float in my brain daily, but one comes into view more than others: Alexander Supertramp watches a herd of caribou run through the snow, their majestic-ness overwhelms him, and we see his eyes well with tears even as his face is lit with a shit-eating grin. I too have been so moved by the natural order of things that I've wept. I too have seen a sun rise behind massive mountain peaks with my mouth hanging open in wonder; I've watched a moose drink from a river; I've seen coyotes cross a barren snow covered butte, their collective breath gathering above like clouds--and I have experienced overwhleming humilty and gratitude.
I love what Christopher McCandlessw dared to do, how he did it. I don't idealize him; I find his story tragic and incredibly sad, but also uplifting. I honor his memory and salute his courage and accept his fallibility. He epitomizes human frailty.
"So many people live within unhappy circumstances and yet will not take the initiative to change their situation because they are conditioned to a life of security, conformity, and conservatism, all of which may appear to give one peace of mind, but in reality nothing is more dangerous to the adventurous spirit within a man than a secure future. The very basic core of a man's living spirit is his passion for adventure. The joy of life comes from our encounters with new experiences, and hence there is no greater joy than to have an endlessly changing horizon, for each day to have a new and different sun."
— Chris McCandless
"...the sea's only gifts are harsh blows and, occasionally, the chance to feel strong. Now, I don't know much about the sea, but I do know that that's the way it is here. And I also know how important it is in life not necessarily to be strong but to feel strong, to measure yourself at least once, to find yourself at least once in the most ancient of human conditions, facing blind, deaf stone alone, with nothing to help you but your own hands and your own head..."
— Bear Meat by Primo Levi
"I knew all the rules/but the rules did not know me/guaranteed..."
-Eddie Vedder
Be at peace, Christopher. We hear you.
13 Comments:
I would like to adress Alaskan Park Ranger Peter Christian's comments that McCandless was 'stupid'. To suggest that he could have been better prepared is obvious and so far from the point as to be REALLY stupid. Somebody who removes themselves from society in every way possible is not likely to be interested in maps for God's sake. He could have stayed at home an been hit by the proverbial bus or bought an SUV a driven there and back with the heating on all the time! However preventable his death was, he must have been aware that death was a real possibility. A genuinely heroic figure that didn't live long enough to gain the all wisdom he cherished.
here here, Darragh, here here. McCandless' odyssey was about more than just trekking into the wild with all the right gear...he was the furthest thing from a North Face wearing gear head that you could get. What's stupid is the lack of compassion many feel for this interpid traveller who tried the only way he knew how to live life honestly and without pretense. We may never understand his motivations, but we CAN honor his memory by not bagging on his lack of preparation. There was no map where Chris went. His map was his heart.
This comment has been removed by the author.
I agree with Peter Christionsons' statements. Jack London was an adventurer, so was Earnest Hemingway and Thorou (sic?) but they did it without killing themselves. Would anyone climb Mt. Everest without the proper training and equiptment? I admire McCandless sense of adventure and search for freedom but think he was an impulsive and spoiled little boy. Maybe if he had grown up in a blue collar world he would have appreciated the things he had. Be an adventurer but don't be stupid (and selfish).
i thought everyone was going to be as stupid as peter christian...he is really stupid. he obviously doesnt get the big picture. chris was doing something amazing and assholes like peter are too stupid to understand.
Peter Christian is obviously "a member of the society" that McCandless rejected. Peter is too shallow to understand the soul of Christopher. Christopher died in what he believed in. He conquered his phony self and tuly found who he was. If we could all be so blessed to die knowing who we truly are and to find our spiritual selves. Let us all pray that Peter Christian will find his true self as did Christopher.
Farls needs a history lesson. Jack London was an overweight alcoholic who wouldn't last a week in the wilds of Alaska. His books depict a romantic notion that he never actually experienced.
And kudos for calling Peter Christian on his comments. We get it Peter, you think your life is better than everyone else and the way to go. Everyone is different, do you really think McCandless would have been happy being a park ranger for 30 years, and then collecting a pension somewhere for the rest of his life?
Excellent comments and insight! I too am drawn to this story, but do not idolize McCandless. I respect what he did and what he stood for. I myself am not made to be as brave and fearless.
I agree that Peter just "doesnt get it" -- he indicates that "he knows the type" because he is one too - this comment also shows (to me) his complete ignorance and presumptions. As indicated several times above, the whole point of challenging ones self is to leave the folds of security and all of the associated safety equipment. Why do people freeclimb cliff faces with no safety rope? To be safe? Or might they be challenging themselves, fully knowing and realizing the very real and distinct possibilty of death. The letter Christopher wrote indicating that he may not be south for a long time seemed eery in its tone - "final climatic battle" and references to possibly not making it back. He definitely knew what he was getting into - he was different from the average young man drawn to Alaska - but people like Peter tend to generalize in their judgements - the ignorant love to lumps "types" together and attempt to boost their own esteem by thinking they are somehow better or smarter than others.
I have read a few of Chris' school articles - I guarantee Peter has never produced anything close to as profound or insightful, and he definitely has a lower IQ than Chris - no offense intended, just an observation.
I doubt very much if you constrasted Peters relatively tame and consevative approach to life to an adventurer like Chris, we would most likely see that Peter never challenged himself in the same ways and to the same extent that Chris did - with his numerous excursions and adventures prior to the Alaska trip - which in Peters view would have seemed "stupid" or "foolish" themselves.
I am no city slicker or urbanite - and I laugh at his comments on the moose meat. Sure, Chris had the wrong information regarding the appropriate way to cure the meat in that region -- and yes he could have done it better if he knew of the traditional native methods -- but keep in mind Peter that Moose also die from natural causes and injury commonly - meaning it was less of a waste specifically because SOME of the meat and possibly the hide were utilized by Chris - wheeas a Moose can easily die somewhere in isolation without ANY predators and very few scavangers finding it - a real true waste. There is some kind of underlying bitte resentment at Chris' "type" by Peter - even though he claims (and probably believes) he is one as well.
I am by no means half as fearless as Christopherr was - but I would wager I am tens times moe adventurous than Peter. As a young man of 19 and 20 built a large wooden raft and with a friend navigated local bay and ocen waters exploring islands and coastline - north of San Francisco where the water can be deadly - and in the "great white triangle". We even navigated to Hog Island in Tomales bay with no tidebook, -- a bay wich is the single lagest great white nursery for shark pups in the eastern pacific, and has wicked tides and large mudflats, in addition to a deep fast moving deep channel. Yeah, we could be called stupid and foolish, but the entire point of the adventure was to test our skills, abilities and stengths WITHOUT the safety of life vests and outboard motors - without the aluminum hull and tidebook. Wooden oars made fom scrap wood - with backups in case they were lost of damaged - no life vests, only small coolers of food and containers of water. We later heard comments such as, "Why didnt you just take a little boat out there? Are you guys stupid?"
It was teacherous several times and twice I thought we might be in serious trouble. Our raft was stout - made of huge timbers and telephone pole sections - with a raised deck - in order to withstand some small waves and our fear of a possible shark attack. We made it though all of our adventures, and looking back these were some of the most personally rewarding accomplishments of my life - more than my degree or success at my career. Guys like Peter, who live in conservative conformity, always relying on the knowledge of others for safety instead of truly testing himself, is nothing like the McCandless "type". Peter seems to be the type that would bring all the necessary essentials to ensure a sterile, predictible, scheduled and homogenized trip.
His comment about the bus - again indicative of his ignorance, and could even be considered "stupid" by Alaskan standards - he indicates the bus got there somehow - but seems to completely forget what season it was and local conditions - did the bus get there during April, May, June or July? Hmm. I would venture a guess that the bus came during summer, when towing conditions in the area would be optimal.
In summary it seems that people love to belittle and bash Christopher mainly because he wasnt the same safe predicable traveler they would be - and simply never grasp the true underlying inspiration.
For me, I think it is specifically this specific trait that draws me to this story - that Chris was a bold, fearless adventurer. In some way I envy the free and adventuous life he pursued. I think all people who are dawn to this story have at least some kind of connection and/or understanding of this trait - the others who seem to harbor this strange animosity - simply will never get it.
We live in a country that proclaims individualism, yet when one pursues his own path--look at even the well-known like Thoreau--they're condemned for it. "Conventional thinking" is that one is to pursue a lifestyle of comfort and consumption. That's why we go to school, right?
Dear Peter Christian,
I can't wait for your version of the correct methodology in the exploration of the human soul in nature. It is sure to be a box office hit and a tale full of witty explanations of the complexities of human nature and the "correct" gear to tote along in our journey to realization. Sure to be about as successful as Gigli casted with a star studded cast of the likes of J-Lo.
The essay you published on Chris was pathetic and irresponsible on so many levels. I can only hope that nobody in his family even heard about it. I can't believe you would reduce his death to suicide. Maybe if you would take one of your allowed twice a day 10 minute breaks from your dream job and pull your North Face turtleneck down so that it is no longer covering your eyes you would be able to see just how ridiculous your statements were. It was never intended to be a story of heroism and Chris was not intended to be portrayed as some hero. He was a very common person. A person searching for answers. This is what draws people to the story, not admiration but understanding. Apparently you've already found all of the answers but that does not give you the right to belittle the rest of us who haven't.
Don't worry it your efforts weren't a complete loss. The essay does persuade me in one way. I am convinced that you actually value the life of an animal (in particular a 1500 pound moose) more than that of a human. Your insecurities and sophomoric view on life exude through the entire statement.
In conclusion, I understand your sense of professional responsibility as a park ranger to shun his behavior in venturing into extreme situations being anything less than unprepared but it sickens me that you reduced his life to stupidity and suicide. America was formed to be an individualistic country in which people were free to pursue the things that make them the most happy. You pursued and gained the happiness through a family and a job and if Chris were alive today I don't think he would have mocked you for doing so. Especially not if you had passed away because, unprepared, you fell asleep behind the wheel on the way to work because you didn't get enough sleep.
As I said, I hope his family has not read your essay. If they have you owe it to them and to those that Chris inspired to make a restatement of the essay.
I think what most people don't get is that the story of Chris McCandless is not necessarily supposed to be heroic. It is simply his story. For good or bad, better or worse. The people who want to skewer him just amaze me. It's not like Chris did this to say, "whoa, I'm a hero, hold me in high regard...blah blah blah." In fact, he seemed to want to escape any of that. What he did was for him. What was said about him after he died was what people saw in his story. It's his story. Like we all have our stories. And in our stories, we don't always make the right choices...we get scared and make mistakes. Chris wasn't perfect, none of us are, but he seemed genuine. Not intentionally set out to hurt others, but do his best to discover himself. Why people want to hang him out to dry for that, I don't get. Everyday, in modern society, many people screw shit up. They are merely living there story. Whether it's Alaska or NYC. So let it rest. Let this guy rest with his own lovely journey.
I have only just recently heard of Chris' story and after watching the film I felt overwhelmed with sadness. I cant imagine the loneliness he felt in his last few moments, having to accept his fate knowing he would never see his family again. We can sit and speculate all day long on why but I just think of all those he met on his journey of discovery and how he impacted their lives, I am a great believer in fate and that everything happens for a reason as harsh a fate as it was we are all fated that way but I doubt we would have seen or done half of what Chris did, but then it is only when we hear of others fates that we question our own.
I just "lost" a loved one that after getting laid off from his job of 20 years, and after his life left him, decided to pull a Chris McCanless. It sucks!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Christian is right, people do stuff like this to die. I know, you guys have only read the book or watched the movie! Don't be so quick to judge. And McCandless was as stupid as stupid can get going into the wild without the proper preparations.
Post a Comment
<< Home